Harff & Gurr (1988): Genocides and Politicides

PS140O section review · Oct 23, 2026

Prof Wasow

2026-10-23

What they did

  • A global survey of massive state repression since WWII
  • Universe: sustained episodes in which the state or its agents impose on a communal or political group “conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or part”
  • 44 episodes meet their guidelines
  • Aggregate fatalities: 7 to 16 million, at least as many as died in all international and civil wars in the period

The Proposed Dividing Line

  • Geno/politicide is an act of the state (or its agents) that kills a substantial portion of a group
  • The difference is in how the state identifies the victims

The Proposed Dividing Line

Victims defined by
Genocide communal characteristics: ethnicity, religion, nationality
Politicide hierarchical position or political opposition to the regime

Same act. Same perpetrator. The category turns on the label the killer uses.

Why invent a word?

  • The 1948 Genocide Convention protects national, ethnical, racial, and religious groups
  • Political groups were cut from the treaty, partly at Soviet insistence
  • Victims killed for their politics had no legal name

“Politicide” fills the gap the law left open. Harff & Gurr use it “in precisely the same way” as genocide.

Six types, with a Table 1 example each

Type Victims are… Table 1 example
Hegemonial genocide distinct groups forced to submit to central authority USSR: Chechens, Crimean Tatars
Xenophobic genocide groups defined as alien and threatening (purification) Ibos in northern Nigeria, 1966
Retributive politicide previously dominant groups, resented for past privilege Rwanda 1963-64: Tutsi ruling class
Repressive politicide parties, factions, movements in opposition Taiwanese nationalists, 1947
Revolutionary politicide class or political enemies of a new ideology PR China 1950-51: landlords
Repressive/hegemonial ethnic groups because they are in opposition Kurds in Iraq, 1959-75

Quick check: G or P?

Four rows from Table 1. The victim column is the only clue you need.

  1. USSR, 1943-57: Chechens, Ingushi, Crimean Tatars
  2. PR China, 1950-51: Kuomintang cadre, rich peasants, landlords
  3. Paraguay, 1962-72: Ache Indians
  4. China, 1947: Taiwanese nationalists
  1. G (hegemonial)    2. P (revolutionary)    3. G (xenophobic)    4. P (repressive)